Today, I discuss false virtues, what they are and why you should avoid them.
Table of Contents
- What Is Virtue?
- What Makes A Virtue False?
- A False Virtue Is Passive
- A False Virtue Feeds Arrogance
- A False Virtue Distracts From True Virtue
- Avoid What Is False
What Is Virtue?
“All that man loses in the pursuit of virtue is comfort.”
Virtue is behavior that shows high moral standards – for example, being generous to those in need or being patient during a challenging time. Although difficult to perform, virtuous actions build stable lives and accomplish meaningful goals.
What Makes A Virtue False?
A false virtue is passive. Courage, Generosity, Industriousness, Discipline, Persistence, Patience, Gratitude, Zeal, Magniminity, Loyalty, Fortitude, Authenticity, and Frugality all require active participation. This active participation is demanding on the individual but enables you to become your best self as you shave off dead weight and strengthen the best within you.
For example, you cannot be passively patient. You must actively cultivate the thought patterns needed to be calm during difficult times. This change benefits you: your thoughts are more precise when the worst comes to bear, you can entertain yourself easily during dull moments, and you prevent others from becoming victims of your emotional trauma. But one cannot cultivate patience sitting on the sofa watching television. You have to participate in the world around you and sacrifice the comforts of emotional instability.
However, tolerance, a false virtue, only requires a lack of standards and the refusal to enforce best behaviors. Similar to counterfeit virtue, false virtues lead men astray. We focus our energies on what is accessible and ineffective instead of what is effective but challenging. Instead of being courageous and standing against evil, we become “tolerant” of such iniquities and consider ourselves morally righteous.
A False Virtue Is Passive
“The man who does not value himself, cannot value anything or anyone.” – Ayn Rand
Virtue is active. You must actively pursue patience by forcibly calming your emotions during difficult times. You must actively be courageous by suppressing your fears and focusing on the truth. You must actively discipline yourself as you fight back doubts and distractions.
False virtue is about passivity. For example, tolerance is acceptance of what is not virtuous. To be tolerant, one only has to deny their standards and refuse to criticize others. Such a “virtue” requires nothing of the individual except inaction.
To do good, one must act. To bring about a better world, you have to achieve the best outcome. There are no standbys when it comes to virtue. If you want to pursue what is morally just, you must act in morally just ways.
A False Virtue Feeds Arrogance
Most false virtue convinces weak individuals they are acting righteously when they are simply following the preapproved behaviors of the mob or the ruling classes.
One may be “tolerant” of bad ideas or harmful behavior. This person may feel his tolerance is a sign of enlightenment, patience, and prudence. However, he is only tolerant because his in-group believes open-mindedness is valuable. He is tolerant because elites have told him that such behaviors prove he is a good man. And while he basks in the glory of his tolerance, poor behaviors are excused, and bad ideas fester and grow unchecked.
Being courageous and standing up against poor ideas or criticizing improper behaviors will earn the ire of the mob and the condemnation of our elites. But this is virtue. One pursues what is correct at the expense of one’s comfort. False virtue promises greatness without discomfort, whereas virtue guarantees excellence at the cost of comfort.
A False Virtue Distracts From True Virtue
Virtue is the foundation of a good life. To live well, you must forgo comfort to pursue sustainability, strength, and virtuous ends. Although discomforting, such pursuit ensures you can withstand hardships when they inevitably arrive. However, a false virtue distorts and distracts, pushing the individual away from good and toward their vices and flaws.
For example, freedom is seen as a virtue. For the virtuous man, freedom is the capacity to pursue the good. It is not a means to an end but a tool in the life of purpose and meaning. One does not fight to be free but is free to fight for what is just and virtuous.
To the weak individual, freedom is an end goal. Freedom exists without responsibility or ties to the systems and society producing such freedom. They see freedom as a virtue even though it distracts from true virtues and the meaningful goals individuals should pursue.
The result? The weak individual basks in his “freedom” to be gluttonous, lustful, greedy, and petty. But he sees his weaknesses as “good” because he is free. Free from responsibility, but not from his vices. Thus, he remains a slave and will never accomplish anything of note.
Avoid What Is False
There is an endless list of false virtues, from humility to obedience and tolerance to apathy; I will cover these individual false virtues later. However, it is crucial to understand that false virtue will distract you and undermine your efforts at greatness.
As with counterfeit virtue, the best way for an individual to fight false virtue is to pursue true virtue. Be wary of those who want you to follow passivity and “collective” goods over your individual goals and virtuous ends.
“Waste no more time arguing about what a good man should be. Be one.” – Marcus Aurelius
- What virtues are the hardest for you to pursue? Do you ever take these virtues and replace them with passive ones? For example, if you struggle with patience and courage do you consider yourself “tolerant”? In what areas in your life can you pursue virtue to rid yourself of false idols and pursuits?
- Do you feel passive? Are you a passive participant in your life, career, family, and physical health? Where within your life are you most active and aggressively trying to excel?
- What’s something you’ve been trying to achieve? How can practicing a virtue help you achieve your goal? For example, if you want to get in shape, how can the virtue of courage enable you to start going to the gym to improve your health?
Please remember that it’s important to do the actionables. You’re not on this earth to simply read but to do. To become an individual, you must act more than you consume.
*Image credit to Unsplash.